Sunday, April 1, 2012

Design Thinking -- a 2 minute introduction

 
In last several years, Design Thinking has been the professed way to innovation. Although started as a product design discipline which equally emphasizes form and function to satisfy needs and desires of the user, it has now evolved into a way to approach problem solving in general.   Leading MBA programs are embracing it in their curriculum . And  Corporate leadership training programs are also trying to integrate some aspects of the Design Thinking.  Checkout Youtube videos on Design Thinking... it certainly seems to be fun, collaborative, magically promising, experiential, right brained, feels right and inspired.  

The table below is an attempt to capture the breadth of what Design Thinking can tackle and some highlights on how the approach is different from the traditional approaches:


Although much is said about what, why, and when for Design Thinking, the “How” feels a bit letdown .. just a different process,  different perspective, different teaming, different style often wrapped in a different type of ritual.  It all feels quite fuzzy, at times touchy feely, lacking specificity,  and the quality of what is produced is often in eyes of the beholder or derived from the reputation of the designer.  

So why are B-schools interested in it? Why should management leaders care about it? Given a practical problem, does  a Designer really have a different problem formulation?   When confronted with the same problem we find the following different styles of thinking and problem formulations:

Managerial Thinking:  Given a business Goal, and a set of Options, select an Option that optimizes the Goal. Assumes that best exists in the given set of options.

Strategic Thinking: Given a business Goal, and a set of Options, first create additional options and then select an Option that optimizes the Goal. Assumes that the stated Goal is the best solution.

 Design Thinking: Given a business Goal, and a set of Options,  question the goal: does the goal satisfy real needs? Iteratively reshape goal and options. 

Seeking beyond given constraints in pursuit of a better solution .. that is the hallmark of Design Thinking.

Monday, July 4, 2011

The Powers of Ten: The Language must change to adapt to change in Scope

Scope creep is a rather common phenomenon. You hire a painter to paint a few rooms and get an estimate. When the work starts you realize that the bathrooms can use fresh paint as well. And the window sills -- can’t have the window sills in the old paint against the fresh paint on the walls. You think this would be a good way to use the leftover paint and should cost nothing extra. The painter is counting additional hours it will take. For him the scope of the job has changed.
Incremental change in scope can often be absorbed within the current arrangement of things. But what happens if the change is rather huge? Seeing the paint job at your home your neighbor Jack drops in and wants his house painted too. Then Gloria from across the street, Steve from the other end of the court, and of course your favorite sister-in-law – they all want their houses painted by this same guy in next week or so. The work has to be done almost in parallel, and our painter doesn’t have enough people, ladders, drop clothes, or spray machines to get the job done. He either has to refuse to take on the new jobs or he has to think at a different level and change his perspective. He has no choice but to invite his competitors to chip in, and himself take on the role of a subcontractor.
  
Should our perspectives change as the scope changes? This question is beautifully addressed by a 9.01 min short movie, “Powers of Ten”.  You can see it at the YouTube link below. As you see it, start with some minimal description of what you see. And then as the scope of the scene changes (due to change in the scale), notice how you have to create a new vocabulary to describe new things and relationships you see.

Here is another one illustrating the same concept:


Both these movies are based on an essay called Cosmic View by Kees Boeke.  One interpretation of this work could be:
A big change in scope invariably requires changes in the language used to address the scope (vocabulary, grammar). Changes in the language is tantamount to creating a new model, a new architectural way of understanding the new reality. A change in the scope requires us to look at things differently and seek out new underlying architecture.
This realization is quite useful in different aspects of our life. Going from being single to being married is a change in scope of the relationship. When a teenage child grows into maturity, there is a change in scope of that relationship.  The scope of your responsibility changes when you go from being an individual contributor at work to being a manager. In each of these scenarios, we have to grow the language to understand the changes, and use new architectural models to adequately address the new demands brought on by the changes in the relationship.
To learn more about Powers of Ten:


Wednesday, June 29, 2011

Scale change may require Rethinking the Architecture

So you have a working system. It could be an apartment kitchen, a highway toll plaza, a medical clinic, a meet-up group, a farmer’s market, or may be just a family of two.  The system embodies certain number of users or participants, finite resources, a few constraints, and some goals. Implicit in the design of the system is the architecture which hopefully streamlines the relationships and interactions between the users, available resources, and the constraints.

What if you added a few more users? Will the design still work? Most likely yes, may be all you need is to add just a few more resources. What if you added 10 times more users? Will the architecture scale up? Just think of your favorite department store during peak hour and imagine what will happen if 10 times more customers were to show up. At some cost you may still be able to make it work – but the cost could be long lines, degraded customer service, and increased customer complaints.  In fact, the increase in cost will be prohibitive, and it may cost your business. On the contrary, will a system designed for say 1000 users a day still be cost-efficient if the user base dropped by a factor of 10? Clearly there is the cost of all the excess capacity and you may be able to reduce some by reducing staffing and inventory. But there are some fixed costs that are not easy to reduce. Just look around and see how businesses are closing down when they loose customers and market share. A change of 10 times in scale simply isn’t easy to absorb.

So what should change when the scale changes by a factor 0f 10? Almost 13-15 years ago I had the privilege to work with Dr. N. S. Sridharan at the AI Center of FMC corp. in Santa Clara. Prior to FMC, Sri was at BBN in Boston and a professor of computer science at Rutgers. Sri later moved to Intel, subsequently assumed the role of Chief Knowledge Officer, took early retirement, and devoted himself to social development in India and African countries. Having been a professor and a world class researcher in computer science and AI, Sri had a deep insight into the nature of computational processing underlying the software systems. He introduced me to what he called systems heuristic: when the scale changes by a factor of 10, more likely than not, the underlying architecture needs to change as well.

 
Why does this make sense? Consider a kitchen in an apartment occupied by a couple. They have a few pots and pans, some serving ware, some groceries and supplies. Each day they decide whether to cook something fresh, or may be dine on leftovers, or just go out. One fine day they are blessed by 8 more guests (not quite times 10). Preparing meals for 10 people is a different type of task. Now they need to make sure that there is a menu which works for most – in a sense spontaneous dining is not a practical solution. They will need more serving ware, not just only more pots and pans but even of different types; they may have to go with paper plates and cups, get a pressure cooker or two, and even buy electric slow cookers. Since the apartment refrigerator isn’t big enough they may have to do grocery almost everyday.  

Although the kitchen is still being used to prepare meals, the process is now quite different. There are new artifacts in the solution (formal menu, pressure cooker, etc.), there may be greater variety of dishes (one set for kids and another for adults), there may be new constraints (say, due to dietary restrictions), and new groupings (may be people will eat in batches rather than dine together).  Of course, having the number of people increase from two to ten will force changes in many aspects of living arrangements – possibly scheduling of shower time, the living room may be transformed into a dormitory in the night, the dishwasher may be used more than once a day, and the spontaneous way of living will give way to a much more planned way of doing things.

In many ways the scale-up did change the reality for the host couple;  they were forced to come-up with many new arrangements. Whatever they did, a system designed for two did not perform well for a group of ten. Clearly, if they could afford, a better solution would have been booking a few rooms in a hotel , get a couple of rental cars, and generally dining out. That would have led to a different architecture and while simplifying living arrangements it would have required more coordination. Architecture always embodies some form of trade-off. Invariably, a large change in scale (up or down) requires us to consider redesigning the entities/actors involved in the problem, their relationships, and their interactions.

Question: What should change when the scale changes by a factor of 10 or more?
Answer: Possibly, the underlying architecture.

Monday, June 27, 2011

Architectural Spaces for Dementia - a New Normal!

Papa turns 85 today. His family is spread over three continents. He lives in his own home with mom, just the two of them. They manage all their work with minimal help from others. He is physically in a good shape (knock on the wood). She cannot move without a walker. He gets easily confused, she forgets little. He wakes up everyday in a world of strangers, feeling forced to live in a house which he doesn't recognize as his, with someone he doesn't remember being married to, but really appreciative for all she does for him. He may not know her identity, but he is crystal clear about the indispensable role she plays, and fiercely defends her when needed. She on the other hand refuses to accept that the learned person and strong personality she has known for six decades, now seems to have dissolved into nowhere. There must be some medicine, a cure, a diet, some holy man, a pilgrimage, a miracle ... she defiantly argues and does not quit her search for a solution. Dementia is not a diagnosis she can accept.

In some ways he is living a wonderful, spiritual and peaceful life. His face shines with innocence, a curious smile, an optimistic twinkle in his eyes. He understands jokes and sometimes works through complex logic. He is generally happy unless he is in pursuit to find something he has misplaced (which he is quite sure that others have hidden it). In his mind he lives with a stranger but still fully trusts her. He is happy to see new faces but only for a short time. He thinks he is 30 years younger, mostly remembers the world before he was married, and is surprised to learn that his parents, uncles, childhood friends are no more. He resents not being able to go places at will, and believes that if only he can get an MBA he may be able to get a job and help mom. He remembers his field of study (but not much else) and has ideas of new products he wants to manufacture.

No matter what the diagnosis, he is very much "living in NOW" and cognitively engaged with the world. He feels concerned about the increasingly commercialization of education in India, and he holds consistent views about the political situation. He still has same notions of good and bad, he is still suspicious about same kinds of people and deeds, and he readily recalls things related to his professional career as a teacher, a principal, and later as a superintendent of schools in the steel city of Bhilai Nagar in India. He may not know the names of his colleagues and subordinates, but he recognizes them when they come to visit him and he is able to engage in an easy smooth conversation about matters related to schools, education, and politics of institutions. Don't ask him to name things or people, go along with pronouns and indirect references, and you can have a rather pleasant insightful conversation. The logic and reasoning is still there though association between things and their names (symbols) has eroded.

We all live in an ever changing architectural space (of things and people, their relationships, and interactions). The internal model of the dynamic world is being constantly updated in our mind. Learning leads to reshaping of the architectural spaces we inhabit. Your internal model may differ from that of mine but it is the commonality of the underlying structure that enables us to learn different languages, communicate, and understand each other despite different vocabularies and grammar.

Papa, despite his dementia, has a consistent model of the world he lives in now. The architectural space he lives in is different from the architectural space in which mom lives, though they occupy the same space-time continuum. In his internal world things do exists and have identities, but often he is unable to recall their names. This does lead to some frustration and awkward conversation, but not much more than that. More significantly, his architectural space has a major discontinuity; the present connects back to a world more than 30 years ago, it is inhabited by people and events from his youthful days, and he often recalls meeting some people from past and visiting those places as if it happened yesterday. He knows people today mostly in terms of their roles, he understands reactions and emotions rather well, he remembers his loved ones and invites them to visit him even though he cannot easily recall their names or name the relationships, and while linguistic connections to his memory may have weakened there is no doubt that feelings of love permeates his mind. He feels his social status is somewhat diminished, and he has concluded that he needs to become financially productive to regain his old self, and to do that he really needs to get accepted into a college.

We think of people with dementia as if they are in a freefall of declining memory, suffering from an irreversible condition of aging, and of relatively limited use to the community. We prescribe to them various medicines and activities to help slow the degradation. Being a civilized people we try to make them comfortable, have no expectations for recovery or a productive existence and meaningful life, and we hope for a peaceful goodbye.

Papa paints for me a different reality. He lives in an architectural space where dementia is a new normal; his demeanor is full of optimism and energy, his attitude embraces the seven Da Vincian Principles (Curiosita, Dimostrazione, Sensazione, Sfumato, Arte/Scienza, Corporalita, and Connessione), and he projects a strong desire to be more productive and relevant. Come to think of it, there is much overlap between his architectural space and that of the rest of us. And there in lies the opportunity for us to be an honored guest in his world and join hime in a more meaningful living.

May be instead of trying to fix or bravely cope with what we see as an irreversible impairment, we need to reach out and connect with him in the overlaps of our architectural spaces, and focus on making the union of the spaces more meaningful. May be we need to accept dementia as the new normal for an ever aging population -- an increasing segment of demographics, and think of designing new habitable spaces that compensate for what may be an unavoidable handicap.

Rather than confine people behind safe closed doors or assisted living institutions, away from our orderly world, may be we need to start creating novel architectural spaces, not only for them but also most likely, as a future home for ourselves.

Happy 85th Birthday, Dad!